|
|
After 12 years observing The Boss,
a lawyer shares lessons from the
best business model
he's seen.
It
was Christmas 1978, and Bruce Springsteen and the E Street
Band were playing at Pittsburgh's Stanley Theater.
A mutual friend asked my wife to relay a message to sax
player "Big Man" Clarence Clemons and ask him
to call her. We had a notion of who Bruce was but had never
heard of Clarence. Clarence answered his phone, immediately
asked my wife how she looked and invited her to his room.
He was disappointed to find that she was married but then
said, "OK. Bring him too." When told that we
had a sleeping child, he asked, "Where do you live?"
Clarence's response seemed strange at the time. Those
who know Clarence would see this as absolutely consistent
with his gregarious nature. |
|
Shortly thereafter, at 1 a.m., all six feet four inches, 275
pounds of Clarence arrived at our Shadyside home. An African-American
wearing a big cowboy hat, his first words were, "It's
not easy getting a cab in the middle of the night in Pittsburgh
when you look like me." We spent the next four hours talking
and laughing, as if we were old friends. I drove Clarence to the
hotel at 5 a.m., and, as he had predicted, several young women
were waiting for him in the lobby. We went to the show that evening.
We were blown away by Bruce and amazed to see the audience go
crazy every time Clarence played a solo. Over the next few months,
we became close friends with Clarence, often visiting his house
in Sea Bright, N.J. It took a day to recover for each day that
we spent with him.
In 1983, Clarence asked me to help him with some business and
legal matters. Later that year, I became his manager, just as
his first solo album was to be released. That meant representing
him in his business dealings with Springsteen's Thrill Hill
Productions and the record label, as well as promoting his independent
career. The initial period of this professional relationship lasted
six years through 1989 with a second term from 1993-95. It included
the hottest series of entertainment events of the 1980s, the 157-show
"Born in the USA" world tour from June 1984 through
October 1985. When tickets went on sale for the Washington, D.C.,
show, the ordering frenzy collapsed the phone system. Nine shows
in the 90,000-seat Los Angeles Coliseum sold out in a few hours.
Over my 35-year career as a lawyer and business consultant, I've
worked with firms of many sizes and stripes. I've seen good,
bad and mediocre management. Of them all, though, the most impressive
business operation I've seen close-up is the entertainment
empire created and ruled by Bruce Springsteen. It's been
over 30 years since the October 1975 day that Springsteen appeared
on the covers of both Time and Newsweek. Since then, he has stayed
at or near the pinnacle of the entertainment world. He has earned
hundreds of millions of dollars, with a level and longevity of
business success that ranks with the most successful corporations.
Many of those corporate success stories have been studied and
written up in the Harvard Business review and other journals.
Consider what follows to be my own case study, based on observations
of the principles that have made what I am calling "Springsteen
Inc.," a business success.
hire well
The culture and tone
of an organization generally reflects the person at the top. And
Bruce should be considered the active, hands-on chairman of the
board, with Jon Landau, his long-time manager and one of his producers,
as the brilliant CEO. The chairman's belief in the CEO was
such that Bruce was willing to interrupt his career for more than
two years in the 1970s to litigate the termination of a previous
management contract in order to work with Landau.
The wisdom of selecting
outstanding executives, staying with them and valuing their opinions
was never more evident than in the success of the "Born
in the USA" album. It is recognized as the catalyst that
took Bruce to super stardom. In retrospect, it might appear that
six top-10 singles from that album made success inevitable. But
album success in the mid-80s required substantial radio airplay
for its singles. Bruce had only achieved one top-five single in
his entire career before that album. He needed a smash first single.
Landau and the executives at Columbia didn't believe they
had it, when, after years of work, Bruce gave them what he believed
was a finished album. Springsteen was angry when Landau told him
he needed to write another song to be the first single. He trusted
Landau, though, and wrote the breakthrough "Dancing in the
Dark." Without that, the album clearly wouldn't have
soared as high and jump-started a world-wide Bruce frenzy.
Landau, however, is only one example of individuals who run a
"rock-solid" organization. Excellence encompasses
the entire team: assistant manager Barbara Carr, road manager
George Travis, personal assistant Terry Magovern and many others.
Bruce has been with the same record label — Columbia —
for his entire career. His attorney has been the legal giant Allen
Grubman of Grubman Indursky Schindler PC. He has used Breslauer,
Jacobson, Rutman & Sherman, the entertainment industry's
leading money management firm. The entire organization's
style is quiet efficiency and effectiveness, a remarkable blend
of competence. Even when Bruce does a solo acoustic performance,
he takes key team members with him. At one solo performance in
Pittsburgh, he had Landau, Carr, Travis and Magovern to meet his
needs. During the "Born in the USA" tour, the road
crew included Bruce's accountants. Nothing is left to chance.
exercise control
Bruce Springsteen and George Steinbrenner are both known as the
"Boss," and that is an appropriate description for
both. Their organizations reflect their respective characters
and characteristics. Steinbrenner exercises absolute control over
the Yankees. It might surprise some to know that Springsteen exercises
absolute control over his domain, albeit in a very different way.
A successful, enduring business enterprise requires maximum control
of its environment, and Springsteen Inc. closely controls anything
and everything it can. Through his publishing companies, Bruce
owns the rights to all of his music. The Beatles lost control
of their music and, consequently, the ability to control their
musical heritage. Michael Jackson bought the Beatles' catalog,
outbidding Paul McCartney for ownership of the Beatles'
songs. For that reason, you see many commercials using those songs.
It is inconceivable that Bruce would allow that to happen to him
and his music.
On stage, Bruce and Clarence played the roles of buddies and
almost equals. In business, The Boss closely oversaw what The
Big Man did. I had to keep Landau informed about everything that
I was doing and planning. A revealing example of the relationship
related to Clemons' record deal with Columbia, Bruce's
label, signed before I represented Clarence. The deal gave Columbia
an option after two albums, allowing the label to abandon Clarence
or continue the contract for two more albums.
In early 1986, I was told by a Columbia executive that the option
was not going to be exercised. I then talked with other labels.
One day after I told Jon Landau that Clarence would sign with
another label, Columbia exercised its option. Springsteen Inc.
did not want its key employees straying too far.
satisfy the customers
Every business publication currently features articles about
how critical it is to be responsive to your customers' demands.
Springsteen Inc. has always given fans superior recorded products
and live performances. He records many times the number of songs
that actually go on a released album. His four-hour concerts with
the E Street Band are legendary. There are no opening acts there.
As Clarence once explained the strategy, "We play until
the audience is exhausted."
One time he fell short. In the fall of 1989, for personal and
professional reasons, Bruce terminated his working relationship
with everyone in the E Street Band except his wife, a back-up
singer, and one other member. He later toured with another group
of musicians, the equal of E Street. However, as well as Bruce
performed with that band, it could not produce the same magical
interactions that fans had come to love in a Springsteen concert.
When the tour came through Pittsburgh in December 1992, there
were not enough people interested for me to even use the tickets
I was allotted.
Bruce assessed the situation and made a change. He brought the
E Street Band together again for recording sessions in 1995 and
to the enormous satisfaction of his fans, full-scale touring in
1999-2000 . The "Reunion Tour" included 15 sold-out
shows at Continental Airlines Arena in New Jersey. It culminated
with 10 sold-out shows at Madison Square Garden in New York City.
His 2002 album, "The Rising," recorded with the E
Street Band, was a critical and commercial success, as was the
tour to promote it.
maintain high quality
It helps that Bruce is a great talent, with many Grammys and
an Oscar for the title track of the movie "Philadelphia."
His commitment to quality is unwavering. And the result is remarkable
customer brand loyalty.
Springsteen's commitment to quality limited his willingness
to work on Clarence's solo albums. On Clarence's first
album, Bruce allowed use of a song he had written, and he was
a producer. He appeared in the first video for that album. With
determination, he polished a car in his role as attendant in a
car wash. Nonetheless, even for a friend, he wouldn't compromise
his standards. On the second album, he wouldn't sing a duet
with Clarence that might have been a No. 1 hit. Narada Michael
Walden, Grammy winning Producer of the Year, wrote a duet for
Clarence with Bruce clearly in mind. Jackson Browne stepped in,
and the duet, "You're a Friend of Mine," reached
top-10 status in cities from the East Coast through the Mountain
States for several weeks during the 1985 Christmas season. After
reaching No. 18 on the Billboard chart nationally, it was not
added to any major West Coast stations' play lists. That
brick wall would have disappeared if Bruce had been involved.
The duet would have continued to advance up the charts. I was
very disappointed Bruce didn't do the duet, yet I couldn't
fault him for believing that the song and Clarence's vocals,
didn't meet his exacting standards.
stay loyal to the brand
Large corporations would do well to mirror Springsteen Inc.'s
consistency in branding a public image. Although a multimillionaire
for decades, Bruce is still seen as a working class hero. Neither
he, nor his music, nor those close to him would ever be allowed
to tarnish or distort the brand.
In August 1985, I met with Phil Dusenberry, vice chairman of
BBDO Worldwide. He is the advertising genius behind Pepsi's victory
in the Cola Wars with Coke. He authorized me to deliver a $6 million
offer for Bruce to make a three-to five-second visual-only appearance
in a commercial starring Clarence. I presented the offer to Landau.
He promised to tell Bruce, but he told me Bruce would never tarnish
his image with a commercial. After that rejection, I went back
to Dusenberry and suggested "Ad Aid" with all fees contributed
to charity. Dusenberry offered to establish a foundation Bruce
would control and to which all fees would be contributed, including
BBDO's, Clarence's and Bruce's. He promised the initial millions
in fees would be supplemented by public fundraising. Even as revised,
Landau said Bruce would not lend his name to a commercial venture.
Bruce did authorize Clarence to do an American Express
print ad with renewal for a second year. I advised Landau that
I was seeking other advertising gigs. He didn't tell me not to
do that, because he obviously didn't believe I might be successful.
But we landed a number of major advertisers. The best offer came
from Diet Coke's agency. Clarence signed to do a commercial with
the emerging star Whitney Houston in late January 1986. A sax
was rigged so that flames would burst from it when Clarence leaped
from a piano and began to play. Bruce stopped by the house the
night before Clarence was to go to Los Angeles to shoot the commercial.
He made it clear to Clarence this type of commercial was inappropriate
for a member of his band. The next morning I had to call and cancel
with the agency representative waiting for Clarence to arrive
on the set. The agency thought his cancellation was related to
Coke's sales to apartheid South Africa. They offered to make a
grand gesture to placate Clarence. The ad was shot without Clarence.
Landau later made clear Clarence could not have done the commercial
and remained in the E Street Band.
Until the 2004 John Kerry candidacy, political affiliation
was absolutely contrary to the brand. By then, Bruce was an entrenched
icon. His uncharacteristic departure from his image and brand
consistency was unlikely to adversely affect business. A more
typical example of Springsteen Inc.'s approach to branding occurred
during the 1984 presidential campaign. In mid-September, then-President
Ronald Reagan's speechwriters superficially looked at Bruce's
songs and invoked his name in a campaign speech. During a concert
in Pittsburgh shortly thereafter, Bruce mocked the president's
speech. This led Democratic candidate Walter Mondale to suggest
that Bruce supported him. That produced an immediate denial from
Landau and a retraction from the Mondale organization.
treat your employees well
The contemporary business wisdom says you must treat
your employees fairly in order to have them deliver outstanding
quality to customers. That's Southwest Airlines' highly publicized
creed as it completes 35 years of growth and profitability. Springsteen
Inc. has always operated this way. Bruce rewarded the E Street
Band's loyalty by making them all multimillionaires via a percentage
of net profits from the "Born in the USA" tour (ticket sales and
merchandising) and from the subsequent Live album encompassing
1975-1985.
The band members' loyalty came principally from Bruce's
leadership. Like soldiers following a great general into battle,
band members believed in their Boss.
I once asked Clarence if he were surprised by the
phenomenal success. He said, "From when I first joined Bruce,
I always knew that this would happen." Unwavering faith in Bruce
withstood early days of long, cold bus rides and plugs pulled
on the sound system when they were opening a show.
Business leaders should learn this from Bruce Springsteen:
Employees will accept tight controls and clear direction and even
allow their egos to serve the leader, if they (a) passionately
believe in the leader, (b) absolutely buy into the direction in
which he/she is taking them, and (c) are generously compensated.
show character and will
Given the tightly controlled nature of the organization,
business publications and MBAprograms may never be able to analyze
Bruce Springsteen's business acumen. If they ever could, they'd
find a man who would have become a successful leader in whatever
industry he chose.
It boils down to character and will. In an age when
corporate executives commit fraud and other crimes, the chairman
of Springsteen Inc. and his management team stand out as exemplars.
This is especially remarkable in an industry in which offensive
and boorish behavior is rarely punished and sometimes adulated.
Bruce is a family man. He has kept his 55-year-old body in game
shape. Like a veteran athlete, he remains at a world-class level
long after most of his peers have retiredor are performing far
below their peaks. He is a loyal friend, even to musicians who
cannot possibly advance his career interests. For many years,
he has worked, appeared and even toured with Pittsburgh's Joe
Grushecky.
My wife and I got a special insight into the source
of Bruce's strength and character when we stood next to his mother
during an L.A. concert. 90,000 people listened in hushed silence
while Bruce told a captivating, graphic story. Mrs. Springsteen
exclaimed, "I don't care if he's the biggest rock and roll star
in the world. If he says f___ one more time, I'm going to wash
his mouth out with soap."

Sandy Neiman,
a Shadyside resident, has been in private legal practice since
1981. Also is a business consultant, he managedĘClarence
Clemons for 12 years.
|